Civil War: Fantastic Four

Book Information

  • Publisher: Marvel
  • List Price: 17.99
  • Colected Comics: Fantastic Four 538-543

Book Ratings

  • Overall: 6
  • Story: 6
  • Artwork: 6
  • Value: 6
  • Cool Factor: 5
  • Can It Stand Alone: 7

What Makes It Cool

The Thing in France is kinda cool, but the bonus material quality was very low.

civil war - fantastic fourAs I really enjoyed the main Civil War TPB, I decided that it would be worth while to collect the whole crossover event, or at least as many as I could easily find fairly inexpensively.  So I grabbed a handful of them and got to reading, little did I know that some of them would suck and even lie in contradiction with the main TPB book they were meant to support, or was it the other way around.  Regardless, continuity in a crossover event is key and in this book at least, Marvel missed the boat.

As one might expect after having read the main book, this book starts in the hospital with the Fantastic Four looking over the concussed form of Johnny Storm after he was viciously attacked on the city streets after the Stamford incident. Almost immediately the conflict between Reed & Sue Richards starts.  Reed is one of the three people instrumental in the designs and plans not only for the enforcement of the Registration Act, but also for the Fifty States initiative and the prison called 42 located in the negative zone.  Susan on the other hand can’t imagine trying to capture and imprison heroes that have not only done a lot of good, but are also friends of theirs.  This rift comes to a head and Sue and Johnny actually leave Reed and the children to come to the aid of those following Captain America, the freedom fighters if you will.  Ben Grimm on the other hand makes his own decision and it’s a good one that I’m surprised more heroes didn’t think of or act on.

show spoiler

In the end, Sue and Reed reconcile but she says something to the effect that things can never be the same again.  I don’t imagine that’s a surprise to any Fantastic Four fan who would have known by now that the two aren’t divorced or separated.

I’m pretty disappointed in this book and I’m keeping my finger’s crossed that not all the Civil War books are not as bad as this one or two of the other’s I have read but haven’t reviewed yet.

Avengers Disassembled

Book Information

  • Publisher: Marvel
  • List Price: $15.99
  • Colected Comics: Avengers 500-503

Book Ratings

  • Overall: 8.6
  • Story: 9
  • Artwork: 8
  • Value: 8
  • Cool Factor: 10
  • Can It Stand Alone: 8

What Makes It Cool

How often are you going to see the death of multiple heroes or the end of the Avengers?

avengers disassembledWow, that’s quite a cast I listed in the tags and I tried to just list those characters that made an impact on the story.  The full cast list would account for almost every Marvel Hero of consequence.  It seems only fitting though to have such a prestigious cast when you end an era.  Don’t get me wrong, I understand that the Avengers were rebuilt not real long after they broke apart, but things could never be the same.  In an attempt to modernize the book Marvel will inject popular characters from other series into the Avengers, they’ll add more of a real feel to the book and probably make it darker as well.  According to Marvel, it had to be done to keep the book alive so there’s no point in complaining about what has been lost.

I knew going into the book that Avengers Disassembled was going to be the breaking point of the team and I had heard mumbled rumors as to what happened in the book, but I wasn’t exactly clear how it would go down.  I was very worried that in order to get to where they wanted to go in the book that it would feel rushed and very contrived.  When I finished the book I have to say that I was pleasantly surprised at the story but still saddened by the loss of what had been, exactly how I think Marvel wanted to end the series.

show spoiler

I’m sure there are others that did not enjoy Avengers Disassembled as I have, it’s too controversial an event to make everyone happy.  It is a more important book than first blush indicates when multiple Avengers titles launched not too long after.  Any fan of the Avengers or just a fan of Marvel in general should pick up this book even if you became a fan after the original Avengers era had ended.